The episode begins with Richard playing with rubber ducks in the bathtub, when he heard the doorbell ring he asked someone to get the door but when they did not, he got up and went to the front door only to discover a delivery slip explain that they miss him. When Richard return back to the house and sees Gumball and Darwin on the couch, he asked why did they open the door which Gumball and Darwin sarcastically ask if they are the servants of Richard and ask him what kind of food he want for breakfast. After realizing it was sarcastic Richard sees the mailman and rush to get his package, only after the mailman laugh and Richard joined in, the mailman replied that since he was late for his package, he must either go to the depot to pick it up or pay the $10 delivery.
After the postman left, Richard has a dilemma as he did not want to go to the depot or nor pay for the $10 delivery Gumball told him to call the post office and said that the postman did not ring the bell that he is forced to go and deliver his package for free.
Later, Richard wonders what his subscription puzzle could possibly be, as the fourth and final puzzle piece was in the package. As he wonders, the doorbell rings and he answers it. Letters on the doormat spelled out, “You Lied”, and Gumball asks him if he knows who did it. Richard suspects Darwin, but Gumball points out the delivery guy did it, as he was standing by his truck. He then yells at Richard saying his reputation is ruined. Gumball then says Richard just wants his package, but the delivery guy tells them he will deliver it two more times. If he misses them, he has to go to the depot.
After the delivery guy left, Richard tells the boys he will stand at the door until he comes back, but immediately flops on the couch. Richard states he can still see outside through the television screen, but gets distracted by the ice cream truck, which is just the delivery guy in disguise. Richard tries to restrain himself, but fails. The delivery guy drags him out to the desert, reveals himself, and drives away, delivering Richard’s package. Gumball and Darwin chase after Richard and find him collapsed with ice cream on his head.
Richard then watches for hours waiting for the delivery guy to come back, but he never does. Richard receives a call from the delivery guy disguised as Nicole. At first, Richard is suspicious, but never notices. The delivery guy tells Richard his wife is in the hospital, but isn’t realized as a trick until Richard and the boys get to the hospital. Through a walkie-talkie, the delivery guy tells them the package is at a collection point for four minutes.
The car was towed away, so the trio proceed on foot. After they miss it, Gumball asks why Richard is doing this, and Richard tells the boys he is doing it for the slobs everywhere, and goes through a short speech. They go through many collection points and fail. Richard gets a call from the delivery guy, who tells Richard to give up. Richard recognizes the sizzling and evaluates it is peanut oil, and tracks it down to Diagnoses Burger. When Richard finds his package, the delivery guy takes it and drives away.
The delivery guy thinks he’s won, but he unintentionally comes back to the house. Richard states Gumball told him to redeliver the package, and Richard did so. Richard then takes the package and closes the door, triumphant. This makes the delivery guy shout, ending the episode.
The episode in general is likely a reference to the movie Die Hard. References include the character of Mr. Gruber and his mentioned brother Hans, both presumably a reference to the character Hans Gruber from the movie, the fact that Mr. Gruber has a very similar voice to said character, the frequent usage of walkie-talkies and elaborate schemes, and the use of Beethoven's 9th symphony.
When Mr. Gruber laughs toward the end of the episode, “Ode to Joy” is heard.
When Richard answers the phone, the tan on his eyes disappears.
The window was thrown away, but it was seen again when Mr. Gruber sends Richard a video.