Aside from being a paper cup with a cover and a coffee cup sleeve, along with thin black limbs, the Coffee Cop sports a police hat, and a badge similar to that of the Doughnut Sheriff's. Unlike the Doughnut Sheriff, he does not wear a uniform. The female variant looks identical, but sports pink lipstick and eyelashes.
"The Faith" A female coffee cup appears guarding the park due to the rabid ducks within it.
"The Shippening": The female version attempts to recover Sarah's notebook. She and the Doughnut Sheriff fall in love, but they are not under the effects of the journal. A blue coffee cup also appears, getting injured by a magic umbrella.