Thread:WaterDemonBaku/@comment-25991365-20140726203648/@comment-25991365-20140730170035

Hold on here. What WhatIAm did was arguably worst and he only served 2 weeks.

I was fine with the other decisions, they seemed plausible. But infinite? Really? I wish we just sticked to one decision and closed the thread because now everyone's  confusing the situation.

Zoe told me before, that since Ced's demotion we have stopped making all sockpuppet usage  result in infinite bans, so why? Especially since he didn't break any major rules. He wasn't exactly spamming or trolling. Yes, he sockpuppeted but his reasons were justifiable. All we really had to do was ban his other account BK and then move on. I wish we could have just kept it at one month.

I don't know, but I feel like whatever I say will be met with backlash now and  the majority of us are eager to see him return anyway, so why are we pushing it? 3 months, that's fine. Every suggestion above I'm fine with,  with the exception of infinite. He never cussed at us or trolled us. Again, WhatIAm revived a troll account and staged a kind of argument on that one, didn't he?

this  shows that. Never realized until then, but what Water did and what WIA did are kindred. Both tried to hide their shady past by staging an arguement or debation of sorts. "Well? Because you trolled maximum overdrive and almost smashed the wiki into tiny nibble bits." is probably his way of  dealing with closure. Yet even after this, he continued to make drama blogs like "I'm leaving!" and even now his user page has negativity written on it.

Water never made any drama of his ban, he just accepted it and took it.

I'm scared of the backlash from all of you are, but I'm willing to offer my 2 cents if it means he won't get an infinite ban, because at the moment we all keep changing our minds.

1 month, 3 months. None of that matters to me, but if someone like WIA is going to get away with 2 weeks after he just broke multiple rules, including grief slinging, then why does Water deserve an infinite ban?

(Though personally I'd rather just decide on one month)

Again, not implying he should get the same or less punishment as WIA, but he shouldn't be a victim of a global ban.